Kate's Diet Isn't Working

[Hale]

http://skyliving.sky.com/news-gossip/kates-diet-isnt-working

We try to wear at least three layers under our winter coats.

Let's hope Kate Middleton isn't doing the same.

That would mean her new snacking diet isn't going too well.

The Duchess of Cambridge is reportedly making an effort to put on a few pounds by treating herself to snacks throughout the day.

Scroll down for the pics.

[Tiara]

"We try to wear at least three layers under our winter coats."
Who do this when a heated car is waiting?  :D

[Jenee]

Fast metabolism or no, there are plenty of ways to gain weight. If Kate really wants to put on weight (and she should, if she's planning on having babies any time soon) she should simply consult a nutritionist.

[cinrit]

Fast metabolism or no, there are plenty of ways to gain weight.

It may rarely happen, but if you're naturally thin, it is incredibly difficult to gain weight.  I can attest to that, and I'm sure I'm not the only one.  When I was Kate's age, I had to consult with my doctor on ways to gain weight because I simply could not, no matter how much or what I ate.  It's just as frustrating for someone who can't gain weight as it is for someone who can't lose weight.  And before anyone points to Kate's weight at university, I also was a normal weight when I was in high school and began losing weight in college. 

Cindy

[Jenee]

May I ask Cindy, was your doctor able to help you gain weight?

[cinrit]

No, Jenee, unfortunately not.  As hard as I tried, I didn't start gaining "appropriate" weight until I was in my late 40's.

Cindy

[Hailey Grace]

It may rarely happen, but if you're naturally thin, it is incredibly difficult to gain weight.  I can attest to that, and I'm sure I'm not the only one.  When I was Kate's age, I had to consult with my doctor on ways to gain weight because I simply could not, no matter how much or what I ate.  It's just as frustrating for someone who can't gain weight as it is for someone who can't lose weight.  And before anyone points to Kate's weight at university, I also was a normal weight when I was in high school and began losing weight in college. 

Cindy

I think it's more frustrating for someone who can't gain weight.  I also was a normal weight in high school and began losing weight when my son was young, even though I ate normally - even more than normal. 

Sometimes the pressures of college (in your case Cindy) or having a baby who required special care (me) or other pressures trigger a change in metabolism.  But as long as you get enough nutrition dense calories daily, those in the medical profession are not concerned - they know when your body adapts to the stress, or the stress goes away, or simply for some not yet understood reason, your body likely will return to a more normal weight. 

[cinrit]

^^ Oh, good ... someone who understands! :blowkiss:  One of the frustrating things about it is that so few people understand.  They assume you're not eating right or not eating enough.  It also doesn't help when you've got a parent who is naturally thin.  My father was thin all his life ... he used to joke that when he took a shower, he had to run around under the water to get wet. :hehe:

Cindy

[Hailey Grace]

 :nod: Yes. 

You will understand this Cindy (although I don't expect that anyone else here will) but what I think happened is that Catherine decided that she would lose a few pounds to look good on her wedding day (not uncommon) and then it was too late when she reverted to a normal diet.  I think she eats a good amount of calories daily now, but the weight is not coming back on.

[cinrit]

^^ Yes.  Very plausible.  She may have a high metabolism, as well ... and even when not very active, high metabolism can have a major impact on weight.

Cindy

[putski]

can we pls stop with the weight talk?  It's an old discussion that frankly does not help anything.  It's also a sensitive issue.  The article posted, to begin with, does not come from a high profile source.  If anything, Kate seems to have gained a little bit of weight since the wedding.  Not a whole lot, but I do see a slightly fuller face and arms.  Kate's weight is her business.  And I am sure like all of us, she's doing what's best for her health. As far I see there's no reason to be concerned, so everyone should just leave it alone.

[Lothwen]

^^ Oh, good ... someone who understands! :blowkiss:  One of the frustrating things about it is that so few people understand.  They assume you're not eating right or not eating enough.  It also doesn't help when you've got a parent who is naturally thin.  My father was thin all his life ... he used to joke that when he took a shower, he had to run around under the water to get wet. :hehe:

Cindy

I remember in the 6th grade when we talked in-depth about eating disorders (anorexia and bullemia) that many of my classmates decided that I had an eating disorder because I was so thin (60lbs in the 6th grade).  So yeah, Kate could very well have high metabolism, but I also think she dieted for the wedding, because she was noticiably bigger at University (not fat, just bigger).  Why she dieted is anyone's guess, and we could probably come up with a dozen different reasons, none of which would be right or wrong. 

[SophieChloe]

Kate has not always been so thin.  Even with a heavy coat on her waist looked tiny.  I'm no fan, but I would hate to think she was - let's say - going hungry - for the perfect picture. 

[cinrit]

I don't know that she deliberately dieted for the wedding, but I think the stress of the arrangements and the knowledge that she would be viewed by millions then, probably caused her to lose weight.  I believe I remember reading that she was exercising, as well.  As for her being not as thin in college, I wasn't as thin in high school, either ... I lost weight in my early 20's without even trying, probably as a consequence of age and metabolism, combined with family history.  It could be the same happened to Kate.  I suppose it's not out of the realm of possibility that there are other reasons, but considering the history with Diana's eating disorder, I'd think the Royals would be on top of something like that if Kate had a problem.  Certainly, William would.

Cindy

[Hailey Grace]

I don't know that she deliberately dieted for the wedding, but I think the stress of the arrangements and the knowledge that she would be viewed by millions then, probably caused her to lose weight.  I believe I remember reading that she was exercising, as well.  As for her being not as thin in college, I wasn't as thin in high school, either ... I lost weight in my early 20's without even trying, probably as a consequence of age and metabolism, combined with family history.  It could be the same happened to Kate.  I suppose it's not out of the realm of possibility that there are other reasons, but considering the history with Diana's eating disorder, I'd think the Royals would be on top of something like that if Kate had a problem.  Certainly, William would.

Cindy

  :goodpost:  and in total agreement with the last 3 words of it.

[Pamela]

Looking at pictures of Kate & Mary standing side-by-side, I can't see that Mary looks terribly different in size than Kate (except that Mary is shorter). Of course, they both are wearing coats, but their waist and shoulder widths look fairly similar. Other women that have been photographed near or beside Kate have looked significantly larger.

[Nitefeatherz]

I can say personally I've always had a hard time gaining weight. I'm not alone in my family- my grandfathers and father both had a hard time gaining weight until they were well into adulthood. Any time I get stressed the weight starts to come off.

Hopefully this is the case with Kate. It's a good sign if she is trying to gain weight- that says that it is more likely just her own metabolism IMO than an eating disorder. Either way I hope William and the family are keeping an eye on it just in case.

[WillKateForever]

Am I the only one to find this article a bit "silly"?
Kate has put some weight on since the tour of Canada,we have all noticed that.She can't put much in such a while.Since she is so tall and naturally slim,maybe indeed is difficult for her to put weight,as before mentioned.I also don't like the chosen photos.Instead of saying that she weighed more during University years,they said she always "used to show some leg".Rubbish.
Also I have a question:does anyone know when and why this photo was taken?I mean the one with the "show some leg" comment.

[Macrobug]

Contrary to some members opinion on other forums who have Kate on death's door, I don't think she is all that bad weight wise.  She is smaller than a few years ago but many women lose baby fat in their mid 20's.  She is tall and has a narrow frame.  Hopefully she will not lose any more weight but as long as she has shiny hair and glowy skin, she is fine.

As someone who gains weight just thinking about food, I understand the frustration of many women in regards to their weight.  Although I envy ( to a degree) those who struggle to gain weight, I can understand the irritation of being judged and harassed about it.  It is no one elses business and people need to keep their opinions to themselves. 

I talk to people about their weight when they see me as their health provider but  I try very very hard to make sure it is not judgemental and doesn't create a barrier for mutual trust.  And being an obviously heavier woman, people do tend to open up to me about it.   Few people are happy with their weight and that is a shame.  And I blame the media and the fashion world for that.

[Orchid]

Kate has always been slim but certainly over the past decade since emerging into the public glare she has lost more and more weight - and then even more leading up to her wedding.

I would suggest her weight is down to a restricted diet and lots of exercise. She clearly wants to look her best and that means being slim to photograph well. Few women in the public eye have little care over such issues.

Her current weight isn't her "natural" weight as past photos have evidenced. Less exercise and more food will restore that though (if she wants to of course). Fertility may, however, be a goal which forces her hand.

[Hailey Grace]

Contrary to some members opinion on other forums who have Kate on death's door, I don't think she is all that bad weight wise.  She is smaller than a few years ago but many women lose baby fat in their mid 20's.  She is tall and has a narrow frame.  Hopefully she will not lose any more weight but as long as she has shiny hair and glowy skin, she is fine.

As someone who gains weight just thinking about food, I understand the frustration of many women in regards to their weight.  Although I envy ( to a degree) those who struggle to gain weight, I can understand the irritation of being judged and harassed about it.  It is no one elses business and people need to keep their opinions to themselves. 

I talk to people about their weight when they see me as their health provider but  I try very very hard to make sure it is not judgemental and doesn't create a barrier for mutual trust.  And being an obviously heavier woman, people do tend to open up to me about it.   Few people are happy with their weight and that is a shame.  And I blame the media and the fashion world for that.

A very thoughtful - and well thought out - post.  :thumbsup:

I remember some of the cruel headlines about Sarah Ferguson when she gained weight just after her marriage.  Even though I have never been a Sarah Ferguson fan, I remember seeing a headline in a tabloid "Duchess of Pork" and was astounded at the cruelty of it.  However, 25 years later, some of the comments about Catherine's weight have topped that many times over.

[Orchid]

Sadly it's now the name of the game. The media is unlikely to change when consumerism is so high for any and all news on weight related topics - especially those concerning celebrities like Kate.

[RoyalB]

Orchid, I feel what you say is absolutely right: Less exercise and more food.   :tg3:

[lnz89]

Orchid, RoyalB;
I can say from personal experience of being a naturally very thin person that less exercise and more food does not equal gaining weight, and can actually result in losing it. Not exercising = losing muscle mass = losing weight and more food, calories (personally)does not make any difference. The only way I have found to gain weight is through exercises that bulk up muscles a bit (IE weight lifting, sprinting instead of long distance running etc).
If she is naturally slim, which she seems to be, then there is no point in speculating on her weight as long as she looks fairly healthy (which she does).
Gotta love how right now in the press she is either underweight or pregnant based on the exact same photos!  :loco:

[SophieChloe]

Hi & Welcome.

But Kate is not naturally thin - she IMO has chosen to be thin for the photos - and now William has made her his wife - it's all about Kate's image all the way.   She does not need to impress William with her 'fun side' any longer - now it's her demure sweet shy side for us - does not wash with me  >(